| Platinum | Milk & Co. Gourmet Cookies |
| Gold | University Square Bakery & Deli |
| Silver | Polestar Hearth |
| Bronze | Decadently Yours |
| Top Pick | Bertinhas Sweat Treats |
| Top Pick | Debar Dessert Café |
| Top Pick | Killer Cupcakes Goremet |
| Top Pick | Newton's No Gluten |
| Top Pick | Top Cakes |
| Top Pick | With The Grain |