| Platinum | Wild Rose Consignment Clothing |
| Gold | Mission Thrift Store Guelph |
| Silver | Consign Your Curves |
| Bronze | Smitten Apparel |
| Top Pick | Guelph Market |
| Top Pick | Plato's Closet |
| Top Pick | Platos Closet |
| Top Pick | Salvation Army |
| Top Pick | The Patch |
| Top Pick | Value Village |