| Platinum | Market Fresh |
| Gold | The Lancaster Smokehouse |
| Silver | Dutch Toko |
| Bronze | Wellington Country Marketplace |
| Top Pick | Angelino's Fresh Choice Market |
| Top Pick | Dipietro Fresh Meat & Delicatesen |
| Top Pick | Euro Mart & Deli |
| Top Pick | Old Fashioned Deli |
| Top Pick | Paola's Fine Cheeses |
| Top Pick | University Square Bakery & Deli |