| Platinum | TOMME Cheese Shop |
| Gold | Sweetcheeses! |
| Silver | Paola's Fine Cheeses |
| Bronze | Dutch Toko |
| Top Pick | Best Baa Farm |
| Top Pick | Chartelli's Fine Wines & Cheeses |
| Top Pick | Gay Lea Foods |
| Top Pick | Green Goddess Fromagerie |
| Top Pick | Market Fresh |
| Top Pick | Stemmler Meats & Cheese |