| Platinum | Victoria's Pizza |
| Gold | Buon Gusto Restaurant |
| Silver | Sugo on Surrey |
| Bronze | The Real Deal Sports Bar and Billiards Inc. |
| Top Pick | Atmosphere Cafe + Etc. |
| Top Pick | Earth to Table: Bread Bar |
| Top Pick | Fixed Gear Brewing Co. |
| Top Pick | Manhattans Pizza Bistro & Jazz Club |
| Top Pick | Pizza Nova |
| Top Pick | Roy's Pizza |
